Evidence and documents
Blue Badge parking charge: Premier Park, Which? and the Appeals Charter
On private land a Blue Badge follows the signs at your entrance, not the council rules on the street. If the badge was valid, the holder was in the vehicle and it was not displayed, a first appeal should drop to £20 for 14 days under the Appeals Charter. Attach a copy with that first submission and keep the confirmation. ParkingPack does not handle court claims.
What to send with a private Blue Badge parking charge, when Annex F is £20 rather than a cancel, and the spam trap from Which?'s November 2026 Premier Park case.
On 5 November 2026 Which? published Oliver Lee's Premier Park file. On 12 June he had parked in a disabled bay at a privately managed shopping-centre car park in Leeds, on the way to Nando's with two disabled sons. The Blue Badge was valid. One of the boys became distressed and the badge was not visible from the windscreen. Premier Park posted £100, or £60 if paid quickly.
Lee says he appealed on 2 July and attached a photo of the badge. Premier Park later told Which? that photo was not on the appeal, so it asked again by email and gave 14 days. The email went to spam. No paper copy arrived. The next letter he saw was a 'Final chance before action' at the full £100, then a debt firm at £170. After Which? contacted Premier Park, the operator cancelled the charge and withdrew it from recovery. That cancel is not a freeze on anyone else's notice.
Step-by-step overview
Use this sequence before you pay or submit your appeal. Match each step to the evidence and deadlines on your notice.
- 1Read the reason line on the notice
Not displayed, wrong bay, or overstay. Those need different evidence. The shop on the sign is not who you appeal to.
- 2Do not pay if you intend to appeal
Paying usually ends it. The 14-day discounted figure is a payment clock, not the appeal deadline.
- 3Put the badge on the operator's file
Copy of the badge valid that day, who the holder was, and that they were in the vehicle. Save the confirmation page and the automated email. Check junk.
- 4Ask for Annex F if it was not displayed
That first appeal should be £20 for 14 days, not an automatic cancel. Ask them to apply it in writing.
- 5If they reject you, use the code on the letter
Premier Park is BPA, so that is POPLA. Court papers are a different process.
What Annex F actually covers
A council Blue Badge does not, by itself, cancel a private parking charge. Private land uses the signs and bay markings at the entrance you used. Yellow-line rights on the public highway stay there.
What the industry Appeals Charter does cover is a missing display. If a valid Blue Badge was not shown, a first-stage appeal should reduce the charge to £20 for 14 days where you supply a copy that would have been valid at the time, and the holder was in the vehicle, driving or not. That is a reduced settlement, not a cancellation. It is also a first-instance rule. A later similar miss sits in the operator's discretion. The government Code laid on 20 October 2026 is not in force yet, and it still treats this as £20.
Displayed, missing, or the wrong bay
It was on display and they still charged you
ANPR photographs the plate at the entrance and exit. It does not photograph the windscreen. Send pictures of the badge in place, the bay markings, and the signs at the entrance you used, taken from driver height if you still can. If the site asked for a clock, include that too. Ask them to treat it as a displayed badge they failed to see, not as a missing badge. That is not the £20 Annex F paragraph.
It was valid, the holder was in the car, and it was not visible
This is Lee's facts, and it is Annex F. Knocked onto the floor, covered on the dash, clock slipped, never got onto the windscreen because a child was distressed. One sentence is enough. Then send a copy of the badge that was valid that day. Ask for the £20 reduction by name. Ask for a cancel as well only if you have something extra.
The holder was not in the vehicle, or the bay was never a badge bay
Annex F does not cover a badge that stayed at home. Do not write that the holder was in the car if they were not. If you parked in an ordinary bay and the signs at your entrance never mentioned Blue Badge parking, a council badge does not rewrite those signs. If the allegation is overstay, many private sites still cap how long badge holders can stay. Ask for the entry and exit times and the wording on the sign. The badge does not usually wipe a long overstay.
What to put in the appeal
Appeal to the operator named on the letter. For Premier Park that is appeals.premierpark.co.uk, not 01302 513232 and not the shop. They will not take an appeal by phone or email. Name the PCN, the registration and the stay date in the first line. Then who the badge belongs to, that they were in the vehicle for the whole stay, and that the badge was valid that day. Attach the copy. Redact the serial number if you prefer.
A first appeal that fits Annex F can be this short:
'PCN [number], vehicle [registration], [stay date]. A Blue Badge holder was in the vehicle throughout. The badge was valid that day. It was not visible from the windscreen because [one sentence]. I attach a copy. Please apply Annex F of the Appeals Charter: where a Blue Badge has not been displayed but the holder supplies a copy that would have been valid at the time, and the holder was in the vehicle whether or not as the driver, the charge should be reduced to £20 for 14 days on a first-stage appeal. Please confirm in writing what is now on the file.'
If they say the photo never arrived
Lee and Premier Park disagreed about whether the badge was attached on 2 July. The operator decides on its own portal. Send the copy again through that portal, or by post to the address on the notice, inside any extra days they gave you. Do not reply to a no-reply inbox. A proper Premier Park submit should show a confirmation page and an automated email. Add noreply_premierpark@eparking.uk, noreply@premierpark.co.uk and noreply@agenagroup.zohodesk.eu to safe senders, and look in junk before you treat silence as a cancel. If neither confirmation arrived, post the same pack.
Which? also found Premier Park and the debt firm each saying the other was responsible. Match the PCN number. If an operator or POPLA window is still open, use it and ask recovery to pause. A jump from £100 to about £170 is usually the industry add-on of up to £70, not a second ticket.
If they reject you
Read whether they offered £20. If you want POPLA to look at the signs, the times or a displayed badge they treated as missing, do not pay that £20 first. Premier Park is a BPA operator, so the rejection should give a POPLA code. Going there usually ends the reduced amount. Put the badge copy in the POPLA pack as well. POPLA will not search an old spam folder.
A county court claim form or a CCJ is a different file. ParkingPack does not prepare court defences or set-aside applications. A Which? article is not a defence. Read the deadline on those papers and get independent advice.
Common questions
The badge was my passenger's. Does Annex F still apply?
Yes, if they were in the vehicle and the badge would have been valid that day. Say that. A badge at home does not cover the stay.
I displayed the badge. Why is there still a charge?
The cameras usually only have the plate. Send photos of the badge in the windscreen, the bay and the entrance signs, and ask them to treat it as a displayed badge they missed. Do not use the missing-display £20 paragraph for that.
Should I pay the £20?
Only if you will live with that outcome. It is the Charter settlement for a missing display, not a finding that the operator was wrong. Paying usually ends a further appeal.
Does this apply to a council parking ticket?
No. Council and TfL PCNs are a different process. ParkingPack does not prepare those cases.
Ready to check your charge?
Enter your notice details free — ParkingPack builds a formal appeal letter, evidence checklist and appeal points for £4.99 before you send it.
